Wagon Wheel Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Wagon Wheel Pizza, a charming gem nestled in Wappingers Falls, NY, where old-school New York pizza reigns supreme. Situated at 2654 E Main St, this cash-only establishment is a haven for pizza lovers craving authenticity and quality without frills.

• Signature Pizzas: Choose from classics like the Garlic Pizza or Pepperoni Pizza, all priced reasonably around $11.49. For a treat, try the Round Wheel Special or Square Wheel Special for a blend of unique toppings.
• Side Offerings: Don’t miss the Antipasto, a delightful mix of meats and olives, or fan-favorite Garlic Bread, perfect for sharing.
• Slice it Up: For a quick fix, grab a Round Cheese Slice at just $1.50.

With rave reviews praising its crispy crust and savory sauce, Wagon Wheel Pizza is more than just a meal; it’s a delicious experience. This is where flavor meets nostalgia, making it a must-try for anyone in the area!