Welcome to Wagon Wheel Pizza
At Wagon Wheel Pizza, we celebrate the charm of old-school New York pizzerias, where traditions run deep and every slice tells a story. Nestled in Wappingers Falls, our quaint establishment specializes in crafting delectable pizzas made with a family recipe sauce, served hot and fresh. Customers rave about our classic pepperoni, crispy garlic pizza, and the signature Square Wheel Special, all embodying the true taste of Italian heritage. Owned by the warm-hearted Peter, our cash-only, non-delivery approach enhances the authentic experience. Join us for a satisfying meal and relish the crispy, light crust that keeps pizza lovers coming back for more!
-
2654 E Main St, Wappingers Falls, NY 12590 Hotline: (845) 297-5940
Welcome to Wagon Wheel Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Wappingers Falls, NY. Located at 2654 E Main St, this old-school pizzeria has become a local favorite for those craving authentic New York-style pizza. With its friendly atmosphere and handmade pizzas crafted by owner Peter, Wagon Wheel Pizza serves not only delicious food but also a slice of nostalgia for many.
This charming restaurant thrives on simplicity, offering a menu filled with classic favorites. Their standout dishes range from the Classic Cheese Pizza ($9.49) to a variety of toppings like Peppers, Meatballs, and Fresh Garlic. For those on the go, they also serve Pizza by the Slice, starting at just $1.50. Customers rave about the Garlic Pizza—an extra crispy option that many, including loyal patrons like Franco C., return for multiple times each month.
- Customer Praise: Diner reviews echo a recurrent theme of satisfaction. "Old-school New York pizza" is how Franco describes it, while others like Mike P. declare it their "favorite pizza." With a commitment to quality, it’s easy to see why Wagon Wheel has garnered such acclaim.
- Side Dishes: The menu also features tantalizing sides, including a Side of Meatballs ($4.50) and a fresh Tossed Salad ($2.75) dressed in options from ranch to Italian.
- Unique Atmosphere: Pay K. captures the quaint charm: "It’s an old-school business, cash only but well worth it." This rustic vibe adds to the dining experience, as guests enjoy their meals in a homey setting that speaks volumes about its dedication to tradition.
The cash-only policy might be a throwback to a simpler time, but it emphasizes the restaurant's focus on good, honest food without the frills. While they don’t offer delivery, as many have noted, the journey to Wagon Wheel is certainly worth it—if only for the fantastic sauce, reputed to be a cherished family recipe, that brings patrons back again and again.
If you find yourself in Dutchess County, do not miss out on the chance to indulge in some of the best pizza around. Grab a slice or two, and immerse yourself in the inviting atmosphere of Wagon Wheel Pizza. You might just discover your new favorite spot.
Wagon Wheel is indeed the best pizza in the area. Hands-down! Old-school New York pizza. No fancy toppings. Doesn't deliver. Only takes cash. Peter the owner is a delightful New York Italian. The menu online is outdated. It's more like $16-$18 per pizza now but still cheap compared to everywhere else. We get the garlic pizza (extra crispy) a few times a month. The best!!!
Great pepperoni pizza if you, like me, want it thin. Tried their side salad with Ranch dressing but a little too soaked with dressing , but fresh and tasty...
Great slices made how I remember. Post good crisp on the crust pretty good for Dutchess County
Good solid slice and friendly old Wappingers atmosphere. I have been there twice since I moved to the area. The sausage mushroom pizza is great.
Old school pizzeria with handmade pizza by the owner. We thoroughly enjoyed our pizza and can't wait to go back.
This is my 2nd time in here and I absolutely love the pizza. It's very delicious and it's always very tasty. The owner is really nice. From the outside it looks as if it's closed . I would suggest brightening up the windows. If you plan to get pizza here you'll need to pay with cash unless he has a ATM in the restaurant. Other then that very delicious pizza.
Pizza is delicious & the owner is super nice. Old school business, cash only but well worth it!
Best pizza around town hands down! He only takes cash and doesn't deliver but it's worth it because it's the best pizza around and the cheapest. The sauce is amazing and is a family recipe passed down. Definitely a must try.
Wagon Wheel pizza is hands down my favorite pizza. I've eaten pizza from an insane amount of different places and I always end up saying "not as good as Wagon Wheel". Is this place fancy, no. But it kind of adds to the charm. The only downside is no delivery but it's probably a good thing because otherwise I'd be 1000 pounds!
This is one of those situations where you've lived somewhere for two years never having tried that one restaurant. We ate pizza at different locations since we moved to the area in 2018... We never felt satisfied enough to return for more. That is until we finally had a pie at Wagon Wheel. I read a review about how good the crust is, and I couldn't agree more: It's crispy and light. We were able to sit outside and enjoy the perk of ordering drinks at the vinyl room. It made for an inexpensive and enjoyable night out to eat. I'm dreaming of my next Wagon Wheel pizza experience!!!!